Valuation Disputes

At Hewlett + Murray, we provide independent valuation expertise in complex and contested settings. Our work often arises in the context of litigation, regulatory and tax scrutiny or disagreements following business transactions. We combine technical precision with commercial insight to deliver clear, defensible opinions that assist legal teams, courts and stakeholders in resolving valuation issues.

02

A beach lifeguard tower, a camera lens, a chain-link fence with spectators behind it, and a close-up of a gear shift knob.

Including:

  • We assist in disputes with the ATO and other tax authorities, offering robust valuations prepared in line with relevant rulings and guidance. Our reports are suitable for use in objection processes, audits and litigation.

  • We support clients in navigating regulatory disputes by undertaking thorough valuations and financial analyses. Our work addresses relevant regulatory requirements and provides evidence-based conclusions to support our clients’ positions.

  • We assist in disputes arising after business acquisitions, including assessing the fair value of acquired assets, intellectual property and goodwill. Our analyses help identify key value drivers and can support negotiations and claims or be relied upon in court.

  • We perform valuations to assist in quantifying financial loss where business interests, equity stakes or intangible assets have been impaired or lost. Our work supports claims arising from breach of contract, business interruption or misconduct. We apply accepted valuation methodologies to determine value or diminution in value and present our findings in a clear, defensible format suitable for negotiation, mediation or court proceedings.

  • We value patents, trademarks, copyrights and trade secrets, helping to facilitate fair compensation and resolution of intellectual property disputes.

  • We provide independent valuations of shareholdings and businesses to assist in resolving disputes between shareholders or partners. Our work supports equitable outcomes in contentious or negotiated scenarios.

  • We assist in family law matters by valuing business interests and other assets, helping parties reach informed agreements in divorce and separation proceedings.

  • When land or business assets are acquired by government or authorised bodies, we assist clients in assessing and substantiating market value and the compensation due under relevant legislation.

  • We support class actions by quantifying aggregate damages, valuing affected assets or interests and providing expert witness services to help courts assess financial impact.

What sets us apart?

Valuation disputes require not only technical proficiency but also the ability to communicate complex valuation concepts clearly and persuasively. At Hewlett + Murray, we are trusted for our:

Credibility: Our team includes experienced expert witnesses whose opinions are relied upon by courts, regulators and legal professionals.

Objectivity: We maintain independence and impartiality, delivering balanced and supportable opinions.

Clarity: We explain valuation assumptions, methodologies and outcomes in a manner that is accessible to both legal and commercial audiences.

Commercial Insight: Our deep understanding of business operations, transactions, and financial reporting allows us to assess value through a practical, real-world lens.

Responsiveness: We work closely with clients and their legal teams to meet tight timelines and evolving case requirements.